New Sheffield Cafe Menu

Welcome to New Sheffield Cafe, a culinary gem located at 3154 Brodhead Rd, Aliquippa, PA. This cafe delights patrons with a robust menu featuring oversized portions and a warm atmosphere. Renowned for its scrumptious breakfast offerings, many guests rave about the beer selection and attentive service.

Hearty Soups: Try the flavorful chili for just $4.95, packed with satisfying spices.
Delicious Burgers: Featured are the mouthwatering mushroom and Swiss burgers, complemented by crispy deep-fried hot pepper rings.
Breakfast Scramblers: Highly recommended, these dishes are a favorite among regulars.
Desserts: Don’t forget to peek at the tempting cakes displayed as you enter!

With a focus on quality and value, New Sheffield Cafe is a must-visit for anyone seeking great food and a friendly atmosphere.

Starters

Hot Cheese Balls

Deep fried hot pepper cheese served with horsey sauce.

$8.50

Fried Banana Pepper Rings

Served with horsey sauce.

$9.25

Provolone Sticks

Served with marinara sauce.

$7.95

Zucchini Planks

Topped with parmesan cheese and served with marinara sauce.

$9.25

Fried Mushrooms

$8.95

Fried Pickles

$8.95

Fried Shrimp App

$9.95

Coconut Shrimp App

6 crispy coconut battered shrimp served with our pina colada sauce

$9.95

Potato Skins

Loaded with cheddar cheese and bacon crumbles. Served with sour cream.

$9.25

Munchie Platter

Potato skins, fried zucchini, provolone sticks, hot pepper cheese balls, and beer battered onion rings. Enough for sharing!

$15.95

Nachos w/Cheese

Our house made tortilla chips topped with cheese sauce and jalapeno peppers. Served with sour cream.

$8.45

Nachos Supreme w/Chicken

Crispy nachos loaded with chicken. Topped with cheese, tomatoes, black olives, and jalapenos. Served with salsa and sour cream.

$15.95

Nachos Supreme w/Beef

Crispy nachos loaded with spicy beef. Topped with cheese, tomatoes, black olives, and jalapenos. Served with salsa and sour cream.

$15.95

Spinach & Artichoke Dip

Fresh spinach and artichokes in a bubbly cheese sauce topped with melted provolone and diced tomatoes. Served with our house made tortilla chips and bite sized Italian bread bites.

$11.95

Buffalo Chicken Dip

Served with our house made tortilla chips.

$11.95

Stuffed Hot Banana Peppers

3 banana peppers stuffed with a mixture of hot sausage and cheese. Topped with marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese. Served with a breadstick.

$12.45

Steak Quesadilla

Made with shredded cheddar, provolone, and grilled peppers and onions.

$12.95

Chicken Quesadilla

Made with shredded cheddar, provolone, and grilled peppers and onions.

$11.95

Shrimp Quesadilla

Made with shredded cheddar, provolone, and grilled peppers and onions.

$13.95

Cheese Quesadilla

$9.95

Veggie Quesadilla

$10.95

Basket of Breadsticks

Garlic breadsticks dusted with parmesan cheese. Served with marinara.

$7.95

Bavarian Pretzel Sticks

6 Bavarian pretzel sticks served with your choice of cheddar cheese sauce or beer cheese dip.

$11.95

Basket of Quip Chips

$7.75

Basket of Fries

$6.25

Basket of Onion Rings

$8.95

Basket of Sweet Potato Fries

$7.95

Basket of Waffle Fries

$7.25

Steak Salad

Our house specialty! We start with a bed of fresh lettuce surrounded with hard boiled egg slices, onions, tomato, black olives, and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries, provolone cheese, and our delicious sirloin.

Chicken Salad

Grilled chicken filet served atop fresh lettuce with hard boiled egg slices, onions, tomatoes, black olives, and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries, and provolone cheese.

Nugget Salad

Tasty fried chicken tenders on a bed of lettuce, provolone cheese, onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperoncini, and golden fries.

Chicken & Steak Salad

Fish Salad

Our lightly breaded cod deep-fried to a golden brown atop a crisp bed of lettuce with hard boiled egg slices, tomatoes, onions, black olives, and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries and provolone cheese.

Gyro Salad

We start with a bed of fresh lettuce, surrounded with hard boiled egg slices, onions, tomatoes, black olives, and pepperoncini. Topped with golden fries, and crumbled feta cheese. Served with our house made dill sauce and a pita.

Caesar Salad

Crisp romaine lettuce topped with croutons, shaved parmesan, and Caesar dressing.

Chef Salad

Fresh lettuce topped with delicious ham, salami, and lean turkey. Garnished with hard boiled egg slices, tomatoes, onions, black olives, pepperoncini, and provolone cheese.

Grilled Shrimp Salad

Our fresh grilled shrimp atop a bed of lettuce with hard boiled egg slices, onions, black olives, and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries and provolone cheese.

Taco Salad

A crisp bed of lettuce topped with onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperoncini, and cheddar cheese. Topped with our house made tortilla chips, chili, and melted cheddar cheese sauce. A Mexican treat! Served with salsa and sour cream.

Tossed Salad

Crisp lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, black olives, and pepperoncini. Served with your choice of dressing.

Salads

Wings

Whole Wings

FlavorsWet:BBQ, Honey BBQ, Carolina Tangy BBQ, Buffalo Bleu, Butter Garlic, Candy Pepper, Garlic Parmesan, Honey Garlic Stinger, Honey Mustard, Hot Sauce, Pineapple Habanero, Sweet TeriyakiDry:CajunDeli BBQSeasoned

Wingers (12)

$17.25

Boneless Wings

Plump, juicy all white meat. They're great! No bones about it!FlavorsWet:BBQ, Honey BBQ, Carolina Tangy BBQ, Buffalo Bleu, Butter Garlic, Candy Pepper, Garlic Parmesan, Honey Garlic Stinger, Honey Mustard, Hot Sauce, Pineapple Habanero, Sweet TeriyakiDry:CajunDeli BBQSeasoned

Hot Roast Beef Sandwich

Lean and thick slices of beef piled high on Italian bread. Served with your choice of mashed potatoes or fries and gravy.

$13.95

Hot Turkey Sandwich

Lean and thick slices of our fresh baked turkey breast piled high on Italian bread. Served with your choice of mashed potatoes or fries and gravy.

$12.95

Hot Hamburger

Our fresh grilled burger on Italian bread. Served with your choice of mashed potatoes or fries and gravy.

$11.95

Gyro

Savory gyro meat, lettuce, tomato, onion, and our fresh made cucumber dill sauce served on pita bread.

$8.95

Italian Hoagie

Generous portions of ham, salami, pepperoni, and provolone cheese. Toasted and topped with lettuce, tomato, and onion. Served with Italian dressing on the side.

$10.95

Philly Steak Hoagie

Thinly sliced sirloin grilled with sauteed mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Topped with provolone cheese on a fresh grilled hoagie bun.

$10.95

Chicken Philly Hoagie

Thinly sliced chicken breast grilled with sauteed mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Topped with provolone cheese on a grilled hoagie bun.

$10.95

Meatball Hoagie

Lori's delicious meatballs topped with our tangy sauce, and melted provolone cheese.

$10.45

Hot Sausage Sandwich

Hot sausage patty smothered in peppers and onions and topped with provolone cheese. Served on a fresh grilled hoagie bun with a side of sauce.

$8.95

Reuben Sandwich

Our tasty corned beef topped with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and dressing. Served on grilled rye bread.

$11.95

Triple Decker

Turkey, baked ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise stacked high between three slices of toasted sourdough bread.

$12.45

Turkey Bacon Club

Turkey, bacon, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise stacked high between three slices of sourdough bread.

$12.45

Fish Sandwich

Generous haddock fillet, hand breaded and deep fried golden brown.

$12.95

Tuna Melt

Our tuna salad topped with American cheese and grilled to perfection on sourdough bread.

$8.95

Grilled Cheese

Your choice of American, provolone, Swiss, cheddar, or pepper jack cheese. Grilled on your choice of rye or sourdough bread.

$6.95

BLT

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on toasted sourdough bread.

$8.95

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

Tender chicken fillet lightly seasoned and grilled to perfection. Topped with lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.

$8.95

Build-A-Burger

Make your own creation. Includes your choice of cheese and up to four toppings.

$10.95

Sandwiches

Baskets & Wraps

Chicken Tenders & Fries Basket

Hand breaded fresh white meat chicken deep fried crispy along side fries. Try them buffalo style or with any of our other wing sauces.

$12.95

Fish Basket

Cod nuggets served with fries and cole slaw.

$12.95

Shrimp Basket

Butterfly shrimp served with fries and cole slaw.

$13.95

Coconut Shrimp Basket

Butterfly coconut shrimp served with fries, cole slaw, and our pina colada dipping sauce.

$14.95

Grilled Chicken Wrap

Grilled chicken in a warm tortilla wrap with lettuce, shredded provolone, ranch dressing, and our red pepper pesto. Served with fries.

$10.95

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Fried chicken tenders tossed in buffalo sauce in a warm tortilla wrap with lettuce, shredded provolone, ranch dressing, and our red pepper pesto. Served with fries.

$10.95

Burger Wrap

Our very own house made angus beef burger wrapped in a warm tortilla with lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, and your choice of cheese. Served with fries.

$10.95